Innovation Nation in the World's Toughest Neighborhood
There is a small framed black and white photograph hanging in IBM’s Israel headquarters, an impressive complex of modern buildings in the Tel Aviv suburb of Petach Tikvah, which shows a group of half-a-dozen bespectacled, smiling young men and women standing arm-in-arm. This was IBM’s Israel team in 1950, during the first year of the company’s operations in a country that was not yet two years old.
Meir Nissensohn, Chairman of IBM Israel, said that even he can’t quite understand why IBM entered Israel back then, but he knew that it was a “pure business decision” not driven by nationalism or religion.
Israel had just won a bloody war of independence against six Arab countries, in which nearly 10% of its population was killed just a few years after World War II. This was a country roughly the size of New Jersey, half covered in desert, surrounded by hostile neighbors, with no natural resources, and still in the midst of absorbing hundreds of thousands of Jewish refugees from European and Arab countries. These refugees lived in primitive shelters while the country faced chronic food shortages and a nearly nonexistent economic infrastructure.
Yet in 64 years, Israel has evolved from a hardscrabble economy relying upon on American aid, tourism, and fruit exports into a hotbed of entrepreneurship and innovation. Israel’s rate of progress toward an innovation-based economy is nothing short of staggering. Today, Israel has the highest density of start-ups per capita in the world, producing more start-up companies than much larger, developed countries like Japan, China, India, Korea, Canada, and the United Kingdom, and attracting over twice as much venture capital investment per person as the United States and thirty times more than Europe.
More than a hundred American firms have opened R&D operations in Israel and many more have acquired companies there, bringing Israel hundreds of billions of dollars in foreign direct investment, creating many thousands of high-skilled jobs, and serving as a key catalyst for Israel’s own innovation boom. IBM is just one of many global companies that have set up shop there, but its story is a telling one.
In 1972, IBM set up its first research and development (R&D) center outside of the United States. Today, this site remains IBM’s largest research lab in the world outside the U.S., and is joined now by dozens of similar centers in cities across Israel that employ more than 1,000 people. The breadth of the center’s research cuts across industries and sectors. According to Nissensohn, the story goes beyond what scientists are doing in the IBM facilities to the wider technologically rich ecosystem in Israel that is IBM’s real laboratory.
“We have a joint value proposition and work with companies across the country to identify technologies that we can together bring to market,” Nissensohn said. Through joint ventures and partnerships, IBM Israel identifies products that compliment the company’s hardware and software capabilities. Through partnerships and joint ventures, IBM brings those solutions to the global market. Nissensohn estimates that IBM Israel plus its collaboration with nearly 150 Israeli companies contributes about $1 billion in revenue per year for the parent company.
What’s more is that Israel has continued to prosper and foreign investment remains despite a multitude of wars and terrorist attacks. In their must-read book, “Start-up Nation: The Story of Israel’s Economic Miracle,” Dan Senor and Saul Singer analyzed Israel’s economic growth in the early 2000s, during the second Intifada, one of the deadliest periods of terrorism, followed by the second Lebanon war and a rain of Hezbollah rockets landing across northern Israel.
They wrote that “Israel’s share of the venture capital market did not drop – it doubled, from 15 percent to 31 percent. And the Tel Aviv stock exchange was higher on the last day of the Lebanon war than on the first, as it was after the three-week military operation in the Gaza Strip in 2009.”
The word “enterprising” in Hebrew translates into two words: ba’al yozma, which literally mean “master of initiative.” The story of Israel as about one of the most enterprising places in the world, jam-packed with masters of initiative, men and women, who helped to transform this country into an international pacesetter for innovation and a veritable playground for cutting-edge technology even amidst great challenge. Israel is having an impact on a wide range of industries from energy to life sciences. For years, Israel has been a critical innovation hub for so many of the American technology giants, such as Intel with its more than 7,500 employees in Israel who have been responsible for some of Intel’s blockbuster hits. American auto giant General Motors and global consumer product giant Proctor and Gamble (P&G) have innovation centers in Israel as well.
“We find technologies everywhere in Israel,” said Dr. Lital Asher, Head of P&G’s Israel House of Innovation. Dr. Asher explained how P&G has leveraged homeland security technology to improve P&G’s ability to understand people’s behavior, relying on new tools to provide insights into how, for example, people do laundry. Dr. Lital said that P&G realized the potential of Israel as a truly unique environment for innovation and established a center which collaborates and co-develops products with the Israel ecosystem: start-up companies, academia, industry, and beyond. Last September, P&G announced a joint venture between Duracell and the Israeli company Powermat, a developer of wireless technology to charge mobile devices without plugging them into a charging source, which is introducing wireless charging stations in New York and has plans for national expansion.
The U.S.-Israel commercial relationship is a growth engine for both of our economies – creating jobs, contributing to economic advancement, and enabling companies on both sides of the Atlantic to innovate, build, and grow new products that transform industries and society. Yet, as the conversation in the States continues to focus on how we can maintain our competitive edge, produce the most innovative companies, and create jobs for the best and brightest, there are also lessons we can learn and best practices we can glean from Israel’s success story in building up this enterprising nation:
- Significant and effective spending on basic science and R&D – The government of Israel makes the highest investments in R&D in the world, totaling 5% of the country’s GNP, compared with an American and an OECD average of 2.5%. Israel has also developed innovative ways to increase the return on its investment. Since 1997, Israel has ranked above Asia and Europe in the percentage of its citizens working in R&D.
- Integration of highly skilled immigrants – More than 25% of the general Israeli workforce holds university degrees. Israel has progressive immigration policies to further boost the strength of its human capital. During the early 1990s, nearly one million people immigrated to Israel from the former Soviet Union, increasing the overall population by 20%. Nearly 40% of those immigrants held academic degrees, many who are scientists, engineers, and specialized technicians. Israel’s immigration policies encourage engineers, scientists, and business professionals to come and stay and build new companies.
- Incorporation of highly trained military veterans and their innovations into the workforce – All Israeli men and women must serve in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). Some serve in special operations units or tank divisions, while others are placed into Talpiot, an elite IDF training force, or Unit 8200, the equivalent of the National Security Agency, where they are part of developing sophisticated scientific and industrial tools for protecting the Israeli homeland. Israel’s private sector knows almost instinctively how to integrate graduates from a technological and progressive army that has spearheaded a high-tech boom by adapting cutting edge defense technologies for civilian applications. These graduates learn to work as teams and improvise under intense pressure, all while receiving formative training in the army's technical units.
- Strong university-industry collaboration – The World Economic Forum ranked Israel seventh among 142 countries in university-industry collaboration for R&D and first in quality of its scientific research institutions. What’s known as “Silicon Wadi” stretches from Tel Aviv to Haifa and is home to much of the high-tech community in Israel. Modeled on Silicon Valley, this region grew up where it did because of a strong partnership between companies and elite tech universities and research institutions nearby, such as the Technion and the Weitzman Institute of Science. IBM’s own R&D facility was founded by an engineering professor who, along with three researchers, was based at the Technion in Israel’s early years; its largest center is currently located on the campus of Haifa University. What’s more, as early as the 1960s all of Israel’s major universities had “technology transfer units” where scientists could patent and spin off research or products for commercial purposes.
- Pro-active and Targeted Government Support – Recognizing the importance of the technology sector to the economic growth and welfare of the country, the Israeli government has over the years provided significant incentives to encourage and support investment. Moreover, the formation of the Israeli venture capital industry—now second only in size of the United States—can be traced back to 1993 when the government decided to establish a fund of funds known as the “Yozma Program.” Under that program, 10 new venture capital funds were formed managing $20 million each, of which the Yozma’s fund held a 40% share. In 2010, there were about 20 venture capital funds operating in Israel to invest exclusively in start-up companies engaged in the development of technological innovation with global application in areas of communication, computer software, information technology, semiconductors, life sciences, medical devices and biotechnology, and homeland security. The government of Israel also promotes government policies which support industrial R&D through mechanisms such as the Office of the Chief Scientist, which develops tech-based partnerships and grant programs, as well as public-private partnerships such as the Bi-national Industrial Research and Development Foundation (BIRD), which was established in the late 1970s by the U.S. and Israeli governments to support private-sector collaboration on industrial R&D.
There are, however, potential challenges ahead for Israel’s economy. With the geo-political shifting sands of the Middle East, Iran’s efforts to build nuclear capabilities, the increasing sophistication of Islamic radicals, critical questions about Israel’s security loom large, as they have since Israel’s establishment. Yet Israelis are resilient and risk-taking and even rank ahead of countries like Norway and Denmark by placing 14th on the United Nation’s World Happiness Report.
Another key set of challenges for Israel comes from within. Israel is dealing with population dynamics that are due to have a large influence on its economic future. For instance, in 2010, workforce participation in Israel was at 64% among the working-age population—significantly lower than the OECD average—due to the large and quickly-growing ultra-Orthodox and Arab-Israel populations whose participation in the labor force is very low. How Israel trains and integrates these communities into Israel’s knowledge-based economy is a serious question.
Another game changer for Israel is the recent discovery of world-class natural gas reserves off its coast, which present a range of possibilities for the country—economic, strategic, and political. Israel will have the opportunity to transform its energy economy from 100% import-based to potentially being an exporter of natural gas and in the process transform Israel’s economy for generations to come. Given that this is an entirely new sector for Israel that has arisen over the last two years, the country has neither the infrastructure nor the know-how yet to access and refine its natural gas resources. If Israel’s track record is any indication, this will be the next frontier for innovation in Israel.
In seeking out the Holy Grail for how innovation happens and how a country effectively fosters it, there is no question that Israel is a critical place to look. In the sixty-plus years since its establishment, Israel’s economy has grown fifty-fold, hitting an important milestone just last year by being admitted into the OECD. Understanding where this entrepreneurial “oomph” comes from and how others can emulate it is the critical question of our time.
Josh Kram is senior advisor for Middle East and North Africa Affairs at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce where he directs the U.S.-Israel Business Initiative.